January, 2013 | Pappalardo & Pappalardo LLP

2013 January


Angelo MacDonald’s client pleads “not guilty” to alleged serial murders

Angelo MacDonald, experienced trial attorney at Pappalardo & Pappalardo, appeared today with client Lucius Crawford at his arraignment before the Hon. Barbara Zambelli in the Westchester County Court, with Crawford pleading not guilty to charges that he killed two women in Westchester. Click here to see video from today’s court appearance.

Crawford was indicted by a Westchester County grand jury for the December 2012 murder of 42-year-old Tanya Simmons in Mount Vernon, and the 1993 murder of 23-year-old Learonda Shealy in Yonkers. Crawford has also been indicted in the Bronx for the 1993 murder of 38-year-old Nella West, and the press have called Crawford a “serial killer.”

Angelo MacDonald is a seasoned trial attorney who has tried more than 60 homicide cases as both an Assistant District Attorney in Bronx County and as a defense attorney. MacDonald is a member of Westchester County’s 18-b Assigned Counsel Homicide Panel and is representing Crawford on the Westchester murder charges.

During today’s arraignment on the indictment, Angelo MacDonald suggested that Crawford may be mentally disabled, referring to a doctor’s report that indicated Crawford’s IQ is 64 with a classification of mild mental retardation. Judge Zambelli ordered a mental health evaluation pursuant to Criminal Procedure Law § 730 to determine Crawford’s competency to stand trial.

Crawford has been indicted in Westchester on two counts of Murder in the Second Degree in connection with Simmons’ and Shealy’s deaths, as well as two weapons possession charges. Murder in the Second Degree under Penal Law § 125.25(1) is a class A-I felony, and for persistent violent felony offenders could carry a sentence of 25 years or possible life imprisonment. Criminal Possession of a Weapon in the Third Degree under Penal Law § 265.02(1) is a class D felony, and for persistent violent felony offenders could carry a sentence of 5 to 7 years or possible life imprisonment.

According to reports, on December 4, detectives arrived at Crawford’s residence in Mount Vernon to investigate the 1993 murder of West. Crawford is said to not have been home at the time, but police entered the apartment and discovered the body of Simmons. Allegedly, his parole tracking ankle bracelet had been removed and found at the scene. Crawford was arrested approximately three hours later in Mount Vernon. It is alleged that while in custody, Crawford implicated himself in not only the Mount Vernon murder but also the Yonkers and Bronx cold cases. MacDonald has indicated his client has denied his involvement in the murders.

Reports indicate that Crawford has a criminal history dating back to 1973 involving various assaults on women in both New York and South Carolina, and that Crawford has spent nearly 30 years in custody. Crawford was released on parole in 2008 after spending 13 years in prison for the attempted murder of a 31-year-old Westchester woman in 1994.

Crawford’s next date in Westchester County Court is scheduled for February 13 before the Hon. Robert Neary.


Angelo MacDonald to appear on tonight’s episode of “True Crime with Aphrodite Jones”

Pappalardo & Pappalardo’s Angelo MacDonald will be featured in tonight’s episode of True Crime with Aphrodite Jones, airing at 10 p.m. on the Investigation Discovery Channel.

In tonight’s episode, “Sex and Death in the O.C.,” Aprodite Jones reports on the murder of Bill McLaughlin and the trial that followed more than 15 years later. McLaughlin was killed by six gunshot wounds to the chest on December 15, 1994, in his home in Newport Beach, California.

The Orange County Prosecutor’s Office accused Nanette Johnston and Eric Naposki of first-degree murder with the special circumstance of murder for financial gain. Johnston met McLaughlin after placing an advertisement for “Wealthy Men Only,” inspiring the title of a recently-published book. Naposki, a former NFL player, was Johnston’s romantic interest.

Naposki reached out to Pappalardo & Pappalardo’s managing partner John Pappalardo shortly after his arrest in 2009. Naposki and John Pappalardo were childhood friends and had kept up their friendship over the years.

Pappalardo & Pappalardo’s Angelo MacDonald represented Naposki in the trial, which concluded in the summer of 2011. Naposki was convicted of the murder, but he maintains his innocence and is currently appealing his conviction and sentence. Evidence presented against Naposki at trial was largely circumstantial, and the gun used to kill McLaughlin has never been recovered.